The Look for Less: Stuart Weitzman Pump

This beautiful suede Stuart Weitzman ‘Stiltspump’ Pump is on sale at Nordstrom now for $199, down from its original $375 price tag (45% off). It’s a beautiful shoe, with its stacked heel and exposed platform. There’s also a black leather version. Heel height is approximately 4 ½” with a 1” platform.

This very similar Steve Madden ‘Disobey’ peep toe suede pump is currently on sale at Nordstrom for $58, down from the original $100 price tag (40% off). I personally adore the hot pink version but it also comes in taupe, black, and turquoise suede. The approximate heel height is 4 1/2” with a 3/4” platform. 

The two shoes are very close in heel height and style. So which would you purchase? The higher end version that’s slightly more deeply discounted? Or the less expensive shoe with more options for color?